Pahia Dairies Limited
Public notice is hereby given pursuant to S.95A of the Resource Management Act 1991 that the following application for resource consent has been received by Environment Southland.
A hearing was held at 10:00 am on 5 October 2023 at Environment Southland, Cnr North Rd & Price St, Invercargill.
The application [reference APP-20222765] is for the following resource consents to authorise proposed activities at 171 Ruahine Road West:
- Land Use Consent to use land for intensive winter grazing.
- Discharge permit to discharge contaminants to land associated with intensive winter grazing.
- Land Use Consent to increase the area of the dairy farm by 100 ha.
Purpose: Dairy Farming Operation
Location: 171 Ruahine Road West, Ruahine at about NZTM2000 1196129E 4854040N
Legal Description of Property: Lot 2 DP 10746, Section 11 and 12 Block V Longwood SD, Lot 1 DP 401670 and Part Section 14 Block V Longwood SD.
Address for Service: Nicole Mesman (nicole@lumen.co.nz), Lumen Environmental Limited, 189 Alford Forest Road, Ashburton.
Full details of this application are also available for inspection at Environment Southland, corner of Price Street and North Road, Waikiwi, Invercargill during working hours (8.00 am to 5.00 pm). Enquiries may be directed to Jade McRae by phone to (03) 211 5115 or by email to jade.mcrae@es.govt.nz.
Submissions on the above application must be received by Environment Southland no later than 5.00 pm, 23 March 2023. A submission form is available below and you may also download a printable submission form and forward the completed form by email to service@es.govt.nz or esconsents@es.govt.nz
Any person may make a submission on the application, but a person who is a trade competitor of the applicant may do so only if that person is directly affected by an effect of the activity to which the application relates that:
(a) adversely affects the environment; and
(b) does not relate to trade competition or the effects of trade competition.
Submissions must be dated and signed (unless submitted electronically) and must include the following information:
- your name, postal address and telephone number (and fax number if applicable);
- details of the application in respect of which you are making the submission;
- whether it is in support of, or in opposition to the application, or is neutral;
- your submissions, with reasons;
- the decision that you wish Council to make; and
- whether you wish to be heard in support of your submission;
and you must also serve a copy of your submission on the applicant as soon as reasonably practicable.
Application Document
s95-95G Notification Document
Supplementary Information
s41D Strike-out Application
- 01 Applicant - s41D Application to strike-out submission - 17 May 2023.pdf (PDF, 171.5KB)
- 02 Submitter - Submissions in response to strike-out application - 9 June 2023.pdf (PDF, 196.8KB)
- 02A Applicant Submissions in response to NZALA - 22 June 2023.pdf (PDF, 97KB)
- 03 Decision on S41D strike-out application Pahia Dairies Limited APP-20222765.pdf (PDF, 594.1KB)
s42A Council Hearing Report and Appendices
Pre-Circulation Applicant Evidence
Pre-Circulation Submitter Expert Evidence
- 01 Statement of Submitter's Evidence - Oska Rego - Associate at HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (PDF, 354.2KB)
- 02 Statement of Submitter's Evidence - James Hook - Director, Principal Planner at Envivo Limited (PDF, 786.2KB)
- 02A Attachment 2 - James Hook evidence - nutritech.co.nz-Feeding Fodder Beet (PDF, 394.8KB)
- 02B Attachment 3 - James Hook evidence - gumboot_score_method_chart_sept2022_update_v2 (PDF, 173.8KB)
- 02C Attachment 4 - James Hook evidence - Intensive-Winter-Grazing-Module-Template-2022 (PDF, 5.8MB)
- 02D Attachment 5 - James Hook evidence - your-winter-grazing-plan-2023 (PDF, 317.9KB)
- 03 Statement of Submitter's Evidence - Dr Helen Beattie - Managing Director of Veterinarians for Animal Welfare Aotearoa (PDF, 2MB)
Submitter Hearing Evidence
- Legal submissions on behalf of NZALA - Dhilum Nightingale 5 Oct 2023 (PDF, 387KB)
- Summary of Submitter's Evidence - Dr Helen Beattie - Managing Director of Veterinarians for Animal Welfare Aotearoa (PDF, 569.3KB)
- Summary of Submitter's Evidence - Oska Rego - Associate at HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (PDF, 601.5KB)
Applicant Right of Reply
- 01 Closing Legal Submissions for Pahia Dairies Limited (PDF, 108.5KB)
- 02 Appendix A - Land Use Consent for Farming IWG AUTH-20222765-01 w Applicant changes (17447058.1) (PDF, 1.2MB)
- 03 Kaimanawa Wild Horse Preservation Society Inc v Attorney-General (17459825.1) (PDF, 277.9KB)
- 04 Upper Clutha Environmental Society Inc v Queenstown Lakes District Council (17459823.1) (PDF, 172.2KB)
- 05 Stewart v Grey County Council (17459824.1).pdf (PDF, 169.8KB)
- 06 Taranaki RC - Decision of Independent Decison Maker - Philip Milne and John Iseli - DecisionAnnexures11May2022 (17459831.1) (PDF, 7.7MB)
- 07 Recommending Report RM23.321.01 Online (17459851.1) (PDF, 257.1KB)
- 07A Otago Regional Council - Land use Consent RM23.321.01 (17459833.1) (PDF, 145.8KB)